~86% lower cost on piping stress analysis through a Pakistan-based engineering vendor instead of a US-based one
The same alternative-solution approach applied for the third consecutive project: HIPPS, CI, Zeon.
Problem
The fabricator quoted approximately USD 25,000 and 6 weeks for piping stress analysis. At that point in execution, the project could absorb neither the cost nor the delay, and the fabricator offered no alternative.
Approach
Applied the approach used on the HIPPS CADWorx redesign (USD 25K quoted, under USD 1K delivered) and the CI check-valve punch (USD 18K avoided): find an alternative that delivers the same engineering outcome at lower cost and in less time. Proposed a Pakistan-based stress analysis vendor managed from the back-office, scoped the work, selected the vendor, and managed the engagement.
Solution
Engaged a Pakistan-based stress analysis vendor, managed the engagement, and reviewed the deliverable against the project’s technical requirements. The work was completed in approximately 1 week at approximately 80% below the fabricator’s quote. Across three consecutive projects, this approach reduced vendor-quoted rework costs by 80% with equivalent engineering quality and shorter schedules.


